Valve’s New Employee Handbook

April 25, 2012 1 comment
Welcome to Valve

Welcome to Valve

Recently Valve’s New Employee Handbook was released online. Whether it was a leak or an intentional distribution of the document by Valve is up for debate, but assuming the contents are legitimate (Valve hasn’t confirmed or denied), the contents are extremely interesting. At times it’s difficult to understand how such a utopia can be a functional business, much less such a successful one as Valve is.

The preface describes Valve as “A place where incredibly talented individuals are empowered to put their best work into the hands of millions of people, with very little in their way. This book is an abbreviated encapsulation of our guiding principles. As Valve continues to grow, we hope that these principles will serve each new person joining our ranks. If you are new to Valve, welcome. Although the goals in this book are important, it’s really your ideas, talent, and energy that will keep Valve shining in the years ahead. Thanks for being here. Let’s make great things.”

Below is a figure from the handbook that shows various interpretations of their organizational structure. For those who don’t know, Gabe Newell is their founder, shown at the top of Diag. 1. All those diagrams show interpretations of the same non-hierarchical structure – the opposite as you’ll see at most medium-sized organizations.

Valve's Org Chart

Valve's Org Chart

For reference Valve had 250 employees as of February 2011; likely 300 now as they mention a 20% employee growth rate. And despite 300 employees, there are no managers! The glossary at the end of the handbook describes managers as “The kind of people we don’t have any of. So if you see one, tell somebody, because it’s probably the ghost of whoever was in this building before us. Whatever you do, don’t let him give you a presentation on paradigms in spectral proactivity.”

Valve's method to working without a boss.

Valve's method to working without a boss.

With the absence of managers, how do employees know what to work on? Who tells them what to do? The answer? The employee does. People work on whatever it is they want. All the desks have wheels so the employees can reorganize around whatever idea or product they find interesting. Want to know where someone is sitting? Log into a special web page that maps the floor plan based on where that employee’s computer is currently logged in.

It sounds crazy, but the proof is in the pudding – Valve is more profitable per employee than Google, Apple, Microsoft, or Amazon with a host of successful games and the most successful online games distribution platform in Steam. They’ve somehow figured out how to make this work. They helpfully provide some guidelines to help employees think about what they should be working on:

  • Of all the projects currently under way, what’s the most valuable thing I can be working on?
  • Which project will have the highest direct impact on our customers? How much will the work I ship benefit them?
  • Is Valve not doing something that it should be doing?
  • What’s interesting? What’s rewarding? What leverages my individual strengths the most?

What about perks? “Sometimes things around the office can seem a little too good to be true. If you find yourself walking down the hall one morning with a bowl of fresh fruit and Stump-town-roasted espresso, dropping off your laundry to be washed, and heading into one of the massage rooms, don’t freak out. All these things are here for you to actually use. And don’t worry that somebody’s going to judge you for taking advantage of it—relax! And if you stop on the way back from your massage to play darts or work out in the Valve gym or whatever, it’s not a sign that this place is going to come crumbling down like some 1999-era dot-com start-up. If we ever institute caviar-catered lunches, though, then maybe something’s wrong. Definitely panic if there’s caviar.”

How does Valve make this work? They hire the right people. “Concepts discussed in this book sound like they might work well at a tiny start-up, but not at a hundreds-of-people-plus-billions-in-revenue company. The big question is: Does all this stuff scale? Well, so far, yes. And we believe that if we’re careful, it will work better and better the larger we get. This might seem counterintuitive, but it’s a direct consequence of hiring great, accomplished, capable people. Getting this to work right is a tricky proposition, though, and depends highly on our continued vigilance in recruiting/hiring. If we start adding people to the company who aren’t as capable as we are at operating as high-powered, self-directed, senior decision makers, then lots of the stuff discussed in this book will stop working.”

The 56-page document is really a fascinating read. It’s always interesting to hear how other companies operate (I’m reminded of Netflix’s presentation from a few years back). Let me know what you think of all this in the comments. Would you want to work there? I sure wouldn’t mind.

Cipher Prime – How Four Guys Consume $15K per Month

February 29, 2012 1 comment
Cipher Prime team

These guys are excited about making games!

Cipher Prime Studios is an independent studio with three games to their credit: Auditorium (Steam, $6.99), Pulse (iPad, $2.99), and Fractal (Steam, $6.99). They recently released a breakdown of how their four-man team consumes $15K each month. At first blush, when comparing to a household budget, that seems like a lot of money. Upon closer inspection you find out that $15K doesn’t go as far as you’d think.

Cipher costs breakdown

Where does $15K go?

Note that equipment and Unity licensing expenses aren’t included, nor is any debt from credit cards. As any business owner is likely to tell you, the largest expense is payroll. In this case the four guys make $625 per week, which is $15.63/hr assuming a 40 hour work week. Expanding that out into a yearly salary these guys make $32.5K. I checked out average game developer salaries, and in 2010, across all disciplines, the average salary was $80,817! That’s nearly 2.5x higher than these guys, implying that a move from an independent studio into a mainstream studio would be lucrative, with the tradeoff being freedom. That survey also captures indie developer average salaries, a group to which Cipher Prime belongs, and the average salary is $26,780, meaning these guys are doing better than most.

Cipher Kickstarter Status

Cipher Kickstarter Status

Unfortunately I don’t know what percentage of the sale price ends up as revenue for the developer, but for now lets assume 80% (if you know a better estimate, please let me know in the comments). The average sales price of their three games is $5.66, which based on our 80% assumption above, means $4.53 is for Cipher Prime. Just to maintain that level of expense Cipher Prime needs to sell 3315 games per month; nearly 40K copies per year. That sales target goes up if they get less than 80% per sale, or sell disproportionately more copies of Pulse (the $2.99 title). Unfortunately I can’t say whether that target is high, low, or reasonable for an indie developer, but it seems like a challenge to me.

The studio would like to make a sequel to Auditorium and have looked to a Kickstarter campaign to help fund development. They’re asking for $60K, implying it would take four months to develop said sequel. The project currently has 335 backers and is up to $11,663 with 30 days to go. Publicity from Joystiq has likely helped matters, and hopefully they’ll make it to their funding goal.

Have any of you readers played one of their games? I know I haven’t yet, but I did start taking a look tonight while writing this post.

Revisiting Personal Game Metrics

February 8, 2012 Leave a comment

The last update on my game play metrics was in June of 2011, so it’s time to see how things fared during the rest of 2011. I’m excited to continue getting more data as the months roll on. Pretty soon I’ll be able to see some real trends.

Game Backlog

I continued to play games in my backlog through the second half of 2011. Well, until the Steam Christmas sale hit and Christmas presents came in. Since I didn’t actually finish those games in December the impact won’t be seen here until we check back in throughout next year.

Average time from purchase to completion in the month of completion.

Average time from purchase to completion in the month of completion.

It’s interesting to see how adding data for months July through December 2011 changed my cumulative metrics. September stayed roughly the same with me finishing games about two weeks after buying them. I now have seven games finished in September, so this small number isn’t due to a lack of data. It must be an intersection of available leisure time, available budget, and interest in a new game that continues to exist in September allowing me to finish new games quickly.

July, November, and December all show noticeable increases in time from purchase to completion (i.e. in 2011 I played games that had been sitting on my shelf for longer than normal). Amazingly, of the ten games I’ve ever finished in July, seven of them were in 2011. Those new data points drove the metric up to over eight months, making it the definitive month for clearing out the back log. Doing the math, that means I’m finishing my Christmas games in July. And although June is an outlier, you can make the case that in each of the first seven months of the year I’m playing December/Christmas games. I don’t start playing anything new until August and beyond.

If you follow the games industry, you may have heard people lament that game releases are heavily focused on the holiday season. Madden, released annually in August, is often considered the start of the fall game season. That signal mirrors my own play metrics; I play the newest stuff in August through December. If the game industry spread out their releases more evenly through the year, would my metrics change? Maybe we’ll be able to see whether there are any yearly changes in my play metrics once I have another year of data under my belt.

Game Completion Age

We’ve already looked at how long it takes me to finish a game after I’ve bought it, so this metric takes a look at how long a game has been released before I finish it. My overall average is twelve months, meaning that in general a game I finish has already been out for a year. This helps keep costs down, which you’ll see when I do my next post on how much I spend on games, but doesn’t do so much to keep me on the cutting edge of games; I’m experiencing 2010 in 2011.

Game age at completion in the month that game was completed.

Game age at completion in the month that game was completed.

In my last update, the games I finished in July were nearly two years old. By adding some more data (I finished seven games in July 2011), that has come down to under 20, but it’s still the month in which I play the oldest games. Conversely, September is the month in which I play the newest games, a mere five months since release.

Improvements

Other than continuing to get more data, the other improvements are ways in which to view the data. So far all of the data has been cumulative, but I’m interested in how things have changed each year. Have my gaming habits changed in the four years I’ve collected data? Am I playing older games now? How does this relate to game spending? Can’t wait to investigate this further.

Categories: Metrics Tags: ,

Vox Gaming

January 4, 2012 2 comments

VoxMediaLogoIf you follow gaming blogs, today you had your mind blown. After some hints, some allusions, and a lot of key departures over the last two weeks, news was revealed this morning that a little-known company called Vox Media was going to make a huge splash in the gaming blog market. This company had hired Chris Grant, former Editor in Chief at Joystiq, to form a super group of bloggers and journalists, and he has done exactly that. The new team is nothing short of impressive. It contains:

  • Chris Grant (link)
  • Justin McElroy (link)
  • Brian Crecente (link)
  • Chris Plante (link)
  • Russ Pitts (link)
  • Griffin McElroy (link)
  • Arthur Gies (link)
  • Russ Frushtick (link)

These are all established names in gaming journalism, with histories at Joystiq, Kotaku, The Escapist, and MTV Games. Chris and Brian have been head-to-head competitors over the last six years, so it’s very surprising to have them under the same virtual roof.  Four writers are from Joystiq, which leaves that site’s future in question. It’s being handed over the Ludwig Keitzmann, a capable writer in his own right, who will attempt to keep Joystiq afloat. The Vox Gaming roster is impressive, and the only other person I’d like to see join is Ben Kuchera from Ars Technica.

Today’s announcement is only that the team has assembled, and will now begin creating the vision and content for the to-be-revealed site. They’ve given themselves a year to get it up, and I expect we’ll see it in Fall 2012. They’re soliciting input from the public as to what content, message, and features we would like included. If you’ve got some thoughts on what would make their site something you’d visit, send one of them a message on Twitter.

Do Not Want

Do not want!

 

Yes, please.

Yes, please.

Vox Media runs a tech site called The Verge, which I had never heard of. If I have any feedback for Vox Games it’s that they should NOT let their site look like The Verge. It’s cluttered, takes forever to load, and is difficult to find whatever it is your looking for. They should borrow ideas from Giant Bomb if they want good layout and design ideas. Those guys really are the cutting edge in game media right now.

I’m excited about the news, if a little disappointed that we’ll have to wait so long to see those guys start writing again. Giant Bomb and Ars Technica are the only gaming blogs worth much right now, so I’m happy to have a new entrant that will push everyone else to up their game.

Categories: Business Tags: ,

Rayman: Origins Delights

December 14, 2011 1 comment

I thoroughly enjoy a good platformer, but this generation of consoles hasn’t seen many high quality ones, especially on the HD consoles. I was searching through XBLA and Xbox Indie Games recently to find a co-op platformer to play with my wife, and ended up downloading the demo for Rayman Origins, which turned out to be a blast. During the Thanksgiving weekend sales I got it for sale on Amazon for $40, although my out of pocket expense was zero due to previous account credits on file. You can’t beat a deal like that!

The art style is cartoony, but so crisp in HD. The environments are colorful, diverse, and delightful. I chuckled last night when I entered a new area and the platforms were pieces of fruit on top of talking forks. Pictures of the game itself can say more than any of my descriptions, so check out the screenshot below, and watch the game in action at Giant Bomb.

The art style of Rayman Origins.

The art style of Rayman Origins.

The controls are not as good as Super Meat Boy, but that’s a really high target to reach. They’re still quite capable although there are times when I want to punch up, but instead punch to the right and fall off a ledge, or other such confusion on direction input. I’m using the analog stick on the 360 controller, but maybe I’d have better luck with the D-pad.

Co-op is fun. When one person dies it isn’t game over, but instead the “dead” person turns into a bubble and floats around the screen until the other person punches the bubble, after which that player reappears and regains control. It can be helpful when one person tries to reach a bauble and the other person hangs out to revive them. If both players die, you restart at the most recent checkpoint. Checkpoints are placed frequently and prevent you from having to repeat too large of a section upon death.

It’s a great game and one I highly recommend. Platforming isn’t a popular genre anymore, and word is that this sold only 50K copies in its first month. With millions of consoles sold, it’s sad to see it do so poorly. It’s still $60 on Amazon, but should go down soon if you’re on the fence. Go try the demo and let me know what you think!

One of the many curious looking bosses.

One of the many curious looking bosses.

Categories: Microsoft Xbox Tags: ,

Desert Bus for Hope and Child’s Play

November 16, 2011 3 comments

My wife and I were recently discussing charity, and when she asked which one I might donate to, I immediately thought of Child’s Play. For those that don’t know, the general premise of the charity is to supply toys and games to children in hospitals; to make their stay in the hospital a little happier than it may have been otherwise. They say laughter is the best medicine, and in that regard Child’s Play helps heal those kids more quickly.

Child’s Play is very community driven, and there are several ways to participate. You can send money directly to the charity, and there are charity auctions, but I think something that makes Child’s Play very unique to the gaming community is the game marathons. People sign up to play certain games over a long period of time (e.g. play all Mario games ever made in 24 hours) and ask for donations to Child’s Play in support. There are many examples, but the best I’ve heard of is Desert Bus for Hope.

There are three things that make Desert Bus for Hope special: 1) The play time isn’t fixed, but increases as people continue donating. 2) They take oddball requests with the donations. 3) They play one of the absolute worst games ever made.

On the first point, the first hour of play costs just one dollar, but subsequent hours cost 7% more (i.e. if you donated the first $2.07, the team would play for two hours). Kind of like a compound interest principle. In 2007, the first year they ran the event, they expected to clear about $5,000, which would mean playing through the weekend. They ended up receiving $22K that first year and played from Friday to Wednesday. In 2010 they raised over $207K which took a full week. They even coined a term called “booray” because a donation means they have to keep playing (boo!), but the money goes to a good cause (hooray!).

On the second point, they interact with the community while playing the game via a chat program, and take requests with donations. They do silly things like play the game upside down, sing the Duck Tales theme song, play with socks on their hands, etc. They provide two streams of the event; one a direct feed of the game, and the second is of the team playing so you can see the shenanigans.

On the third point, let me just outline a few details about the game to show just how bad it is. You drive a bus from Tuscon to Las Vegas, in real time, at a top speed of 45 miles per hour. The road is completely straight, but the bus has a slight pull to the right, which requires frequent adjustments by the player. If you drive off the road a tow truck picks you up and drives you back, also in real time. It takes eight hours one way, but if you make it to your destination you get one point, then turn around and drive back.

The game was part of an unreleased Penn & Teller minigame collection for the Sega CD in 1995. The games were intended as pranks you can pull on your friends.

The Desert Bus for Hope 2011 run starts in less than two days. Take a minute to go check it out, and if you’ve got a few bucks to spare, consider donating. The money goes directly to Child’s Play.

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free